If you would like to receive these stories in your mailbox - email [email protected]
Ethnic Media Insights 2026 |
Ethnic Media Insights 2026 |
|
The anglophone referendum story is question 10. Fifteen days out, the multilingual press has filed that one and moved on to two things Alberta is not saying out loud: what its premier thinks of Ottawa's trade war, and what the other nine questions mean.
The first silence is Smith's. When Carney walked out of the Washington talks on August 22, every premier but one backed him. The one was reported from Brampton and Surrey. Asma Saleem on Radio Humsafar's Urdu service (August 23) and Jinny Sims on Radio 1200 AM in Surrey (August 24) both noted that Alberta's premier had expressed disappointment and urged renewed negotiations. The next day Sims relayed Jason Kenney's reminder to Conservatives that they had campaigned on dollar-for-dollar retaliation and should remember their own speeches before arguing against it. Kenney told The Canadian Press the same week that Canada should not start by listing what it will not do in reprisal. Smith's answer came a month later, on OMNI BC's Punjabi Focus (September 28), after her Calgary meeting with Doug Ford: 97 percent of Alberta's goods cross the border tariff-free, against about 80 percent of Ontario's; she does not believe the President is trying to shut down Alberta's energy industry; she would like a national agreement to send two or three million barrels a day south, inside a comprehensive package. That, she said, is what the difference in tone between Ford and herself comes down to. Calgary Chinese covered the same meeting the same day as an energy summit: the Northern Shield corridor from Hardisty to Sarnia, David Cameron and Margaret Atwood on the bill. No tariffs, no dissent. The people counting Alberta's barrels in the meantime are in Hong Kong. The South China Morning Post (September 21) reported China's August crude and LNG imports from Canada rising sharply, with analysts calling Canada an emerging key trade partner as Ottawa diversifies away from Washington. Edmonton's Vietnamese daily (August 26) read Beijing's praise for Carney's "Chinese-style counterattack" as a bid to turn Canada's export dependence into someone else's leverage. For a province about to vote on whether it could go it alone, the market for its one product is being redrawn by two capitals, neither of them Edmonton. The second silence is everyone else's. Connect FM Edmonton (Punjabi, September 28) and Urdu World Canada in Calgary (September 28) both reported that no premier has taken a position on Smith's four constitutional questions: abolishing the Senate, provincial appointment of judges, opting out of federal programs while keeping the money, provincial law over federal law in jurisdictional disputes. Rishi Nagar on Red FM Calgary (September 28) added that Yukon, Nunavut and the Northwest Territories will comment after the result. The voters are quiet too. Janet Brown's September poll, carried by Asian Tribune in Edmonton (September 27) and on Nagar's show, has 49 percent undecided on the nine non-separation questions, 54 percent for more provincial control of immigration, and 63 percent saying immigration benefits Alberta. Calgary Chinese (September 26) spelled out what the five immigration questions ask for: authority to restrict provincially funded health care and education by immigration status, a 12-month residency wait and fees for non-permanent residents, with the rules to be written after the vote. Joseph Schow went on Red FM's Punjabi morning show (September 28) to say the questions do not target permanent residents or new Canadians. Ipsos, cited in the same bulletin, has more than 60 percent voting yes to them. Put the two silences together. The communities most reliably against question 10 are the subject of questions 1 to 5, half of them have not decided those, and the only government outreach on record is one minister on one Punjabi morning show. Meanwhile the economic case for staying is being made, in Chinese and Vietnamese, by people who have noticed that Alberta's leverage this autumn is Ottawa's quarrel with Washington, not anything Alberta holds on its own.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|
|
|