If you would like to receive these stories in your mailbox - email [email protected]
Ethnic Media Insights 2025 |
Ethnic Media Insights 2025 |
The Changing Face of Canadian Politics: Ethnic Representation in the 2025 Federal Election - Part II5/8/2025 While Part I of this series examined how ethnic media interpreted the historic gains in representation and the dramatic reshaping of party dynamics, Part II shifts focus to the broader policy landscape and how diverse communities are responding to evolving national priorities. From trade tensions and industrial policy to foreign affairs and immigration enforcement, ethnic media continues to reflect a wide spectrum of perspectives—often raising questions overlooked in mainstream discourse. This segment explores how multilingual outlets are framing Canada's next steps and what their coverage reveals about emerging challenges and expectations in a rapidly diversifying political environment. Ethnicity and Political Affiliation: Punjabi and Chinese Representation The 2025 election saw a record-breaking 22 MPs of Punjabi origin elected to Parliament, consolidating their position as one of Canada’s most politically active ethnic groups. This surge in representation was particularly evident in Brampton, where all five ridings elected Punjabi candidates. Ontario and British Columbia emerged as key hubs for South Asian communities, with Punjabi MPs playing a significant role in shaping the political landscape. The Liberal Party remained the dominant choice for Punjabi representation, building on its successes in 2019 and 2021. This trend reflects the party's consistent outreach to immigrant communities and its policies supporting multiculturalism and social programs. The Conservative Party, although making some inroads, struggled to gain significant traction among Punjabi voters, while the NDP experienced a notable decline, partially attributed to the waning influence of Jagmeet Singh’s leadership. For Chinese representation, 9 MPs were elected in 2025, primarily from urban centers in Ontario and British Columbia. The Liberal Party again secured the majority of Chinese representation, with prominent figures like Shaun Chen and Jean Yip leading the way in the Greater Toronto Area. However, the Conservative Party faced challenges in appealing to Chinese-Canadian voters, whose concerns over hardline stances on China and limited cultural engagement overshadowed the party’s economic platform. The trends from 2019 and 2021 reveal a steady preference among Punjabi and Chinese communities for the Liberal Party, which has positioned itself as a champion of diversity and immigration. However, the 2025 election also highlighted the potential for these communities to consolidate further under targeted outreach and culturally relevant policies. The Rise of Ethnic Representation in Canada Ethnic representation in Parliament has grown steadily over the last three election cycles. In 2019, approximately 15% of MPs were from diverse ethnic backgrounds, a figure that increased to 18% in 2021 and reached 21% in 2025. This upward trajectory reflects the growing multicultural demographics of Canada, as well as the strategic efforts of political parties to engage immigrant communities. Federal trends indicate that South Asians and Chinese Canadians are driving this rise in representation, particularly in urban ridings like Brampton, Mississauga, Vancouver, and Richmond. Provincially, these communities have also made significant gains. In Ontario, South Asians dominate ridings in Brampton and Mississauga, while Chinese representation is strongest in Markham and Scarborough. British Columbia continues to be a hub for Chinese representation, with South Asians gaining influence in Surrey and Burnaby. Historically, this rise is part of a broader trend that began in the late 20th century as immigration reshaped Canada’s demographic landscape. However, the record-breaking representation in 2025 suggests that this is not merely a gradual shift but a reflection of concerted efforts by communities and political parties to ensure diverse voices are heard. Other Ethnic Groups: New Voices and Persistent Gaps While Punjabi and Chinese communities dominated the narrative of ethnic representation in 2025, other groups also made significant strides. Filipino-Canadian MP Rechie Valdez, elected under the Liberal Party, became the first Filipino-Canadian woman in Parliament, a milestone celebrated widely within her community. Tamil representation also grew, with candidates gaining ground in suburban ridings like Scarborough. However, gaps remain. Ukrainian representation, historically strong during the Harper era, has declined, with only two MPs of Ukrainian origin elected in 2025. This decline comes despite high diaspora engagement due to the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. Similarly, Italian and Spanish-speaking MPs remain underrepresented, reflecting a lack of targeted outreach to these communities. Afro-Canadian representation, while growing, is still not proportional to the community’s demographic size, signaling the need for greater inclusion efforts. Policy Focus: Advocating for Multiculturalism and DEI Ethnic representation is not merely about numbers—it is also about the policies that these MPs champion. The Liberal Party has consistently emphasized multiculturalism and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) in its platform. Policies such as expanding immigration pathways, funding anti-racism initiatives, and strengthening social programs resonate strongly with immigrant communities. The Conservative Party, while focusing on economic integration and credential recognition for immigrants, has faced challenges in aligning its platform with the cultural priorities of diverse communities. Its hardline stance on immigration caps and contentious foreign policy decisions, such as the approach to China, have limited its appeal to many ethnic groups. The NDP, traditionally a champion of equity-focused policies, has seen its influence wane, limiting its ability to advocate for DEI effectively. This decline underscores the importance of leadership in maintaining a party’s relevance among diverse communities. A Global Perspective: How Canada Compares Canada’s progress in ethnic representation stands out among multicultural democracies. In the United States, ethnic representation in Congress is driven by majority-minority districts, but deep partisan divides often hinder cohesive progress on diversity-focused policies. The United Kingdom has seen notable growth in South Asian MPs, reflecting efforts to integrate diversity into its centralized political framework. Australia, however, lags behind, with limited ethnic representation in Parliament despite its multicultural population. Canada’s approach—rooted in targeted outreach, proportional representation, and a commitment to multiculturalism—offers valuable lessons for other democracies. However, challenges remain, particularly in ensuring equitable representation for all ethnic groups and addressing systemic barriers to political participation. Conclusion: Toward a More Inclusive Democracy The 2025 federal election underscored the growing importance of ethnic representation in Canada’s political landscape. From record-breaking Punjabi representation to the historic election of Filipino and Tamil MPs, the results reflect a nation that is increasingly embracing its diversity. However, persistent gaps in representation for some communities and the decline of traditionally equity-focused parties highlight the need for continued efforts to ensure inclusivity. As Canada moves forward, the role of ethnic representation will only grow in significance. By amplifying diverse voices and championing policies that reflect the lived realities of all Canadians, the country can continue to build a democracy that truly embodies its multicultural identity.
0 Comments
New Faces, New Questions: Ethnic Media Reactions to Canada’s 2025 Election Results - Part I5/6/2025 Canada’s 2025 federal election delivered historic shifts—not only in who will govern, but in who holds political power within the country’s cultural communities. While mainstream coverage centers on Mark Carney’s Liberal minority and Pierre Poilievre’s failure to secure his seat, ethnic media has illuminated a deeper narrative, one that probes issues of representation, belonging, and national cohesion from community-specific vantage points.
Representation and Reaction One of the most striking outcomes of the election was the record-breaking 22 MPs of Punjabi origin elected to Parliament. This surge was especially visible in Brampton, where all five ridings went to Punjabi candidates—an achievement widely reported across Indian and Chinese-language media. In Vancouver, Chinese-language outlet Van People acknowledged the milestone but also reflected unease among some readers. Online commenters expressed concerns about whether these new MPs would focus on shared Canadian values, Indigenous reconciliation, and bilingualism—underscoring tensions around political integration in a multicultural democracy. In contrast, Punjabi-language media embraced the result as a breakthrough moment. Red FM in Toronto and Hamdard Weekly in Mississauga portrayed the elections as proof of political maturity within the Punjabi-Canadian community. NDTV in New Delhi highlighted that over 6% of Parliament is now composed of Punjabi-origin MPs, calling it a powerful symbol of diaspora influence on the global stage. A New Political Era for Chinese Canadians Chinese-Canadian candidates also saw major electoral gains, with nine winning seats across Ontario and British Columbia. Vancouver’s Vansky spotlighted high-profile victories, including Shaun Chen and Jean Yip, as markers of the community’s rising engagement and trust from voters. The election of Wade Chang in Burnaby Central, where he unseated NDP leader Jagmeet Singh, was particularly significant. Canada News Network in Vancouver highlighted Chang’s platform, which prioritized healthcare reform and a proposal to transform the BCIT area into a Pacific tech hub that would strengthen Canada’s economic and scientific links with Asia. Still, some cautionary notes emerged. Articles in Van People and Canada News Network echoed frustrations among voters over neglected urban infrastructure and unfulfilled promises from long-standing MPs. The celebratory tone was paired with an insistence on accountability. The Collapse of the NDP—and Jagmeet Singh Nowhere was the shift in political fortunes more dramatic than in the collapse of the New Democratic Party and the personal defeat of its leader, Jagmeet Singh. Once viewed as a symbol of progressive, multicultural politics, Singh lost his seat in Burnaby Centre, and the NDP’s national seat count fell from 24 to just 7. Coverage in Punjab Star (Mississauga) and India’s Dainik Jagran interpreted Singh’s loss as the end of an era, pointing to his past association with Khalistani activism as a liability—particularly during a period of strained relations between India and Canada. ABP News (India) noted that many Indian-origin voters viewed Singh’s stance as oppositional to India’s interests. At Red FM in Brampton, commentary acknowledged Singh’s impact on Canadian politics but emphasized that the NDP’s failure to carve out a distinct platform—and its dependency on the Liberals—ultimately eroded support. On Toronto’s Radio Humsafar, callers voiced frustration that the party had become politically stagnant and unresponsive to evolving community needs. Carney’s Win: A Cautious Reset Ethnic media coverage of Mark Carney’s victory was largely characterized by measured optimism. Carney’s technocratic reputation, combined with his promise of renewed diplomatic outreach, especially toward India, was seen as a potential reset after the contentious Trudeau years. In New Delhi, Amar Ujala and Dainik Hindustan framed Carney as a chance to repair damaged bilateral relations and highlighted his visible efforts to engage with Indian-Canadian communities—attending temple festivals and signaling openness to strategic cooperation. In Montreal, the Romanian paper Accent praised Carney’s economic expertise and his emphasis on defending Canadian sovereignty amid escalating U.S. trade pressure. Zycie, a Polish-language weekly in Toronto, echoed cautious approval while warning that voters may quickly tire of continued Liberal dominance if reforms are not delivered. Meanwhile, Goniec, another Polish outlet in Toronto, was openly skeptical, branding Carney a "media product" and predicting more of the same under his leadership—a sentiment that echoed in corners of Russian and Ukrainian media as well. Electoral Integrity and Community Trust One of the most widely discussed—and controversial—election moments in ethnic media came from Chinese-language WeChat groups in Edmonton, where a video surfaced showing election staff in Hamilton placing ballot boxes into a private vehicle. The footage, reported by Edmonton Official WeChat, sparked intense outrage and skepticism. While Elections Canada downplayed the incident as procedural, online posts asked bluntly: “If this happened in China, would Canada not call it election fraud?” For many immigrant communities, trust in institutions is not automatic—it is earned. When transparency falters, ethnic media becomes the platform through which these concerns are aired, debated, and legitimized. Beyond the Headlines As the national media pivots toward post-election strategy and party leadership speculation, ethnic media remains focused on more foundational questions: Who speaks for immigrant communities? Does descriptive representation translate into policy impact? And will Ottawa treat diversity as an asset or a wedge? From Mandarin-language commentary in Vancouver about political integration, to Punjabi talk shows in Brampton questioning economic priorities, Canada’s ethnic media doesn’t just report the news—it redefines the terms of political engagement. Nationalism, Leadership, and Identity: Ethnic Media Perspectives on Canada’s 2025 Election4/28/2025 As Canada heads toward its April 28 federal election, ethnic media outlets across the country are capturing a version of this campaign that looks very different from what mainstream coverage presents. While national headlines focus on polls and party platforms, conversations in Punjabi, Chinese, Hindi, Portuguese, and other languages reveal a deeper story—one shaped by nationalism, economic anxiety, leadership shifts, and questions of identity.
Nowhere is this more evident than in the way Donald Trump’s shadow looms over Canada’s political landscape. Across Bengali, Hindi, Spanish, and Punjabi outlets, Trump’s tariffs, trade wars, and provocative rhetoric—such as his threat to "make Canada the 51st U.S. state"—have reframed this election as more than a domestic contest. This external pressure has fueled a wave of nationalism, with hosts on Punjabi WTOR Nagara Radio in Mississauga attributing record-breaking advance poll turnout in Brampton to “Trump’s tariffs, his perceived interest in making Canada the 51st U.S. state, and his focus on Canadian resources.” Similarly, a Chinese-Canadian family told Ming Pao Toronto, “Trump’s tariffs definitely influence our voting decisions,” underscoring how cross-border tensions are resonating at the community level. Ethnic media narratives often contrast newly appointed Prime Minister Mark Carney’s calm, technocratic approach with Pierre Poilievre’s more aggressive style. During the English-language debate, a host on Oakville’s CJMR 1320 AM Rangla Punjab observed that “Carney remained calm and responded intelligently”—a performance that won the radio host’s praise. Yet, skepticism about political transparency persists. Commentators on Vancouver’s Connect FM 91.5 Punjabi program pointed out that “Conservative candidates are avoiding traditional media to avoid questions and are using social media to reach out to voters,” raising concerns about accountability in campaign strategies. Economic concerns dominate discussions, with ethnic media tying global pressures directly to household realities. Romanian outlet Accent Montreal emphasized that “tariffs and Washington’s hostility towards Canada are dominating this election campaign,” linking foreign policy to anxieties over inflation, housing affordability, and job security. Meanwhile, Punjabi outlets amplified warnings from Liberal candidate Ahmed Hussen, who stressed on PTC North America TV that cutting social programs like childcare and dental care would “make life more expensive” for ordinary Canadians. China-Canada relations add another layer of complexity, particularly within Chinese-language media. Coverage frequently highlights dissatisfaction with both major parties—criticizing the Liberals for governance missteps and the Conservatives for their hardline stance on China. As one commentator on the Chinese-language Van People website in Vancouver put it, “We are tired of being caught between geopolitical games. Every election, Chinese Canadians are treated as suspects or pawns, not citizens with real concerns.” This frustration extends beyond foreign policy. Vancouver’s Canada News Network (Chinese) noted that the focus on China “often becomes a political tool, overshadowing critical domestic concerns like inflation, public safety, and the cost of living—issues that matter most to Chinese-Canadian voters.” Immigration remains a flashpoint where policy meets personal impact. A Hindi-language article in Dainik Hindustan from India bluntly stated, “Now it is not easy to go to Canada—both candidates for the post of PM are unanimous on stopping immigrants from coming.” Punjabi programs in Canada echoed fears about how immigration caps intersect with strained housing and healthcare systems, with OMNI News TV Punjabi noting that while “immigrants matter” in key ridings, many are left questioning whether services can keep pace with population growth. Professor Andrea Lawlor, speaking to OMNI TV Focus Portuguese, highlighted how outreach to newcomers has become central to party strategies: “Politicians realize that new Canadians vote, they are interested, and they are looking for opportunities to become more immersed in the system. It’s a win-win for politicians to gain voters and for newcomers to feel enfranchised and part of Canadian political culture.” Yet, Lawlor also warned of declining trust in institutions and the American-style rhetoric shaping this election, noting that voters are looking for leaders who can “be the adult in the room” amid U.S.-Canada tensions. Questions of representation and identity politics are also front and center. Leaders’ visits to temples and gurdwaras, alongside the rise of South Asian and Asian candidates, are closely tracked. Hindi-language outlet Amar Ujala from India reported that “65 candidates of Punjabi origin are trying their luck in the field of politics,” while Mississauga’s Punjab Star observed that this surge “signifies a broader movement towards inclusivity”—but also emphasized the need for candidates to “elevate the voices of their communities in a meaningful way,” beyond symbolic representation. Frustration with the political process is palpable across communities. On Toronto’s Sargi Vela Radio (Punjabi), a caller challenged perceived media bias, asking, “What have the Liberals done wrong to you?” after hearing multiple hosts advise against voting Liberal. Reports of election sign vandalism and concerns over paid endorsements further stoked debates about fairness and democratic integrity. Ultimately, ethnic media reveals an election shaped not just by party platforms but by deeper undercurrents of economic insecurity, national identity, and geopolitical anxiety. Whether it’s a Chinese-language outlet warning of being “caught between superpowers,” a Punjabi host urging voters to “educate themselves before voting,” or a Bengali commentary observing that “Trump’s policies are a crucial element shaping the upcoming election dynamics,” these voices highlight the lived realities behind policy debates. As Canadians prepare to cast their ballots, ethnic media offers a vital lens into how communities are experiencing this moment—not as a simple choice between red and blue, but as a negotiation of identity, security, and belonging in an increasingly uncertain world. In the quiet conversations happening in community centers, local radio stations, and ethnic newspapers across Canada, the federal election takes on dimensions rarely captured in mainstream coverage. As Canadians prepare to cast their ballots on April 28, MIREMS' multilingual media monitoring reveals the rich tapestry of perspectives flourishing within Canada's diverse cultural communities.
Trading Winds from the South Conversations about Canada-US relations echo through media of many languages, each community processing these concerns through their unique cultural lens. A Vietnamese-language analysis on Culture Channel examines how shifting trade patterns might reshape Canada's economic landscape, noting that goods once bound for American shores may now arrive in Canadian markets, creating both opportunities and challenges for local industries. This theme finds resonance in Hindi-language media, where discussions center on diplomatic approaches to managing cross-border relations. Meanwhile, callers to Punjabi-language radio programs thoughtfully explore which leadership qualities might best serve Canada's interests in this complex international environment. A Mosaic of Political Engagement Within Canada's cultural mosaic, political affiliations reflect the diversity of the country itself. Chinese-language outlet Van People offers a window into a spirited NDP rally in British Columbia, where community members shared their political journeys and the values guiding their electoral choices. Across the country, Punjabi-language radio conversations reveal thoughtful deliberations about economic policy and leadership vision. Ukrainian-language publications highlight policy proposals concerning international affairs, particularly regarding Ukraine, showing how global concerns shape local voting considerations. The Rhythm of Democracy "The immigrant vote mirrors many of the same concerns as the broader Canadian electorate," observed University of British Columbia Professor Irene Bloemraad in an OMNI News Punjabi Edition report. "We all worry about our communities. We all have similar concerns about jobs and housing." This sentiment finds nuance in the words of Olga Stachova, CEO of immigrant association MOSAIC, who gently reminds us that "there is no one immigrant vote. We are diverse communities." This diversity of thought weaves through conversations in many languages, with each community bringing its unique perspective to the electoral tapestry. As Professor Bloemraad notes, these voices carry particular significance: "Immigrant voters have greater weight in Canada than in the US because a higher percentage of immigrants become citizens, and more immigrants care about voting because they think their vote matters." New Voices in Parliament The journey of representation unfolds through stories like that of Filipino-Canadian MP Rechie Valdez, who shared with OMNI Filipino her experience of bringing new perspectives to Parliament. Her narrative of navigating traditional institutions while carrying forward her cultural heritage illuminates the evolving nature of Canadian democracy. This theme of representation resonates in conversations about leadership across multiple communities, highlighting the ongoing dialogue about what it means to see oneself reflected in Canada's political landscape. Weaving the Whole Cloth The true portrait of Canadian democracy emerges not from any single narrative, but from the intricate interweaving of voices across languages and cultures. While English and French media provide one perspective on the election, these multilingual conversations reveal the full dimensionality of Canadian civic life. As one caller to a Punjabi-language radio program observed, the election ultimately isn't about any single issue or leader, but about "what kind of Canada we want to build together." This sentiment, expressed in different words across different languages, perhaps best captures the essence of what binds these diverse perspectives together. In living rooms and community spaces across the country, Canadians of all backgrounds engage in the democratic process through their unique cultural lenses, each adding a vital thread to the nation's political fabric. The conversations happening in languages beyond English and French aren't separate from the national dialogue—they are essential components of it, offering insights that enrich our understanding of Canadian democracy in action. MIREMS continues to monitor these vital conversations, providing a bridge between communities and helping organizations understand the full spectrum of voices shaping Canada's political landscape. As Canada's federal election unfolds against a backdrop of global uncertainty, communities across the linguistic spectrum are engaging in thoughtful conversations about their place in Canada's future. Through the lens of ethnic media in multiple languages, MIREMS offers a glimpse into these rich dialogues—conversations that often remain invisible to mainstream coverage but reflect the depth and diversity of Canadian democratic participation.
A Tapestry of Concerns Walk into a polling station in Scarborough, Vancouver, or Montreal during advance voting, and you'll encounter a mosaic of voters, each bringing their unique perspectives to this democratic exercise. A South Asian couple, patiently waiting in line at a Scarborough polling station, shared with Ming Pao reporters their reflections on Canada's place in a changing world. Nearby, a Chinese-Canadian family discussed economic considerations that would influence their ballot choice. In Vancouver's Chinese Cultural Centre, Mrs. Guo expressed surprise at the Easter weekend turnout, while in Burnaby, a voter named Martin appreciated the organization of advance polls despite unexpected crowds. These small moments, captured in Van People's Chinese-language coverage, paint a picture of civic engagement that transcends linguistic barriers. International Relations: A Common Thread Across various language communities, Canada's international relationships have emerged as a central consideration. Romanian-language media outlet Accent Montreal observes how attention has shifted toward external relationships and trade partnerships, reflecting widespread interest in how Canada positions itself on the global stage. This theme resonates in conversations happening in community centers, local radio programs, and family gatherings. Professor Andrea Lawlor, speaking with Portuguese-language media, noted this shift in focus and the evolving nature of political discourse in Canada. Chinese-language media has offered nuanced historical perspective on Canada-China relations over two decades. Vansky presented readers with a thoughtful examination of how diplomatic approaches have evolved across different administrations, noting how complex international relationships interact with domestic community experiences. Local Concerns in Global Context While international affairs feature prominently, community media hasn't lost sight of local concerns. In Punjabi-language programming on CJMR 1320 AM, discussions addressed housing affordability, access to healthcare, and the interconnection between immigration policies and community development. French-language L'Express highlighted the French-Canadian Cultural Federation's advocacy for arts funding in minority Francophone communities, with Federation President Nancy Juneau emphasizing that culture represents "a main course" rather than a dessert for linguistic minority communities. In Portuguese-focused ridings like Davenport and Mississauga-Lakeshore, OMNI Focus has documented candidates discussing housing affordability, climate initiatives, and relationships between different levels of government—demonstrating how national policy discussions find unique expressions in local contexts. Leadership Through Different Cultural Lenses Each cultural community brings distinct perspectives to their assessment of party leaders. Van People's Chinese-language analysis offered thoughtful character sketches of each leader's debate performance, highlighting communication styles and strategic approaches. Nash Montreal provided Russian-language readers with reflections on how the debates might influence voter decisions in the campaign's final days. Hindi-language NDTV took a different approach, explaining distinctive features of Canadian democracy to readers, including voting rights for incarcerated individuals and the structure of Parliamentary democracy—offering valuable civic education to community members. Representation Evolves Throughout this election, Punjab Star and other publications have noted the growing representation of diverse candidates. The participation of over 70 candidates of Asian descent, including many from South Asian backgrounds, reflects an evolution in Canadian political representation. The increasing presence of women candidates from diverse backgrounds, including 13 Punjabi women seeking office, suggests continuing transformation in who shapes Canada's political future. In Brampton, community events have brought together established political figures and community leaders, as documented by Punjab Star, showcasing the integration of cultural communities into Canada's political landscape. Listening Across Languages As election day approaches, these multilingual conversations continue to evolve, offering perspectives that enrich our understanding of Canadian democracy. By listening across languages, we gain insight into the hopes, concerns, and aspirations that animate voters from diverse backgrounds. The tapestry of voices captured in ethnic media reminds us that Canadian democracy speaks in many languages, but converges around shared questions: How do we build sustainable prosperity? How do we navigate complex international relationships? How do we create communities where everyone belongs? Though expressed in different languages and informed by diverse cultural contexts, these questions reflect a common engagement with Canada's democratic process—a process that continues to evolve through the participation of all who call this country home. This narrative draws from MIREMS' multilingual media monitoring of community perspectives on the 2025 Canadian federal election. By listening to conversations happening in over 30 languages, MIREMS provides a window into how diverse communities engage with and contribute to Canadian democratic dialogue. While Carney and Poilievre exchange scripted jabs on the debate stage and mainstream commentators dissect tariff threats, a powerful political undercurrent is emerging in Canada’s ethnic communities—one that could upend polling projections and determine which party forms government on April 28.
MIREMS’ multilingual media monitoring reveals a parallel campaign unfolding outside the English and French-speaking mainstream. In this space, immigration—not tariffs—dominates discussion. These voices, often marginalized in national discourse, may ultimately deliver the final verdict. THE IMMIGRATION BETRAYAL: PUNJABI MEDIA REFLECTS DISILLUSIONMENT The Liberal Party’s pivot from its once-open immigration stance has fractured long-standing loyalties in Punjabi-language media—a space that once reliably leaned red. The tone is now one of disappointment and frustration. “Many immigrants are leaving Canada to go to other countries or return home,” reported Arsh Chawla on CJMR 1320 AM’s Rangla Punjab, capturing widespread concern about a loss of talent in sectors like healthcare, where staffing shortages are already critical. The economic ripple effects are visible, including falling rental demand in student neighborhoods as international students disappear. More politically damaging is the silence from both major parties on the future of those same students. “Neither the Liberals nor the Conservatives are talking about whether they have any plans to provide a pathway to permanent residency for these students,” noted one caller to Radio Humsafar. This neglect could prove costly in the 905 region of Ontario, where dense immigrant populations often decide tight races. For now, both major parties appear more concerned with not alienating anti-immigration voters than with retaining traditional immigrant support. TRUMP’S “51ST STATE” TALK: NOT LOST IN TRANSLATION, BUT REFRAMED While much of English-speaking Canada recoiled at Donald Trump’s “51st state” comments, Hindi-language outlet Amar Ujala provided a radically different interpretation. The publication emphasized Press Secretary Leavitt’s framing of annexation as an economic opportunity, quoting Trump as saying, “the people of Canada will benefit greatly by becoming the 51st state.” This reframing reveals a strategic blind spot in Canadian politics—the assumption that all communities respond to nationalist rhetoric in the same way. For audiences with strong transnational ties, economic pragmatism can outweigh traditional notions of sovereignty. “LIKE ONE OF US”: WHY LIBERAL BRAND LOYALTY ENDURES Despite policy backtracking and Carney’s technocratic image, the Liberal Party continues to benefit from cultural affinity within some immigrant communities. “The Liberals seem familiar—like one of us,” a 60-year resident said on CHLO AM 530’s Guntas Radio, capturing a recurring theme: emotional identification can outweigh policy disappointment. In contrast, Conservative messaging often focuses on economic management, with limited cultural engagement. While Poilievre’s cost-of-living platform resonates in part, it’s met with concern among others. “The Conservatives' policies are said to make cuts to many things, including jobs and benefits,” one caller warned. The core battleground here is not purely policy—it’s cultural trust. This intangible factor continues to elude traditional polling methodologies. QUEBEC NATIONALISM THROUGH A RUSSIAN LENS Russian-language outlet Nash Montreal provided a detailed analysis of how both Carney and Poilievre invoked the nationalist slogan maîtres chez nous (“masters in our own home”) during their televised appearances on Tout le monde en parle. The coverage highlighted how both leaders co-opted Quebec's sovereignty rhetoric to stake claims to economic nationalism, while accusing one another of hollow promises. “The Prime Minister responded with a smile, noting that Poilievre seemed to hear him—‘and that’s good!’” Nash Montreal reported, capturing the theatrical nature of their rivalry. This kind of bilingual performance politics is carefully parsed in ethnic media—and increasingly influential. CAPITAL PUNISHMENT: AN UNEXPECTED ECHO In a surprising turn, the issue of capital punishment surfaced in Punjabi-language political discussions. A caller to Radio Humsafar’s Khabarsar suggested, “Instead of spending resources on keeping such criminals alive in prison, Canada should consider reintroducing capital punishment,” in response to Poilievre’s tough-on-crime stance. No major party has broached the subject, yet its emergence in ethnic discourse illustrates how communities may interpret messages through unexpected cultural or legal frameworks. These unintended consequences underscore the risks of one-size-fits-all campaign messaging. “POLLS ARE PROPAGANDA”: DISTRUST IN THE SYSTEM Perhaps the most politically consequential insight is the deep skepticism toward polling itself. Across multiple language platforms, callers voiced concerns about manipulation (“The Liberals are rigging the opinion polls”) and questioned the validity of surveys altogether. This level of distrust, if widespread, undermines one of the core tools political campaigns use to navigate elections. If large segments of the electorate no longer believe in polling, the stage is set for outcomes that defy conventional forecasting—akin to Brexit or Trump’s 2016 win. THE VERDICT: A NEW ELECTORAL KINGMAKER EMERGES As national campaigns focus on televised debates and English-language coverage, they risk missing the real story: the ethnic vote is more influential—and more complex—than ever. MIREMS’ media monitoring shows that immigration policy, cultural familiarity, and economic pragmatism drive engagement in multicultural communities. These factors rarely surface in mainstream coverage, yet they dominate discussion in key battleground ridings. The question isn’t whether ethnic communities will shape the outcome of the 2025 election—it’s whether political leaders will realize their power in time. MIREMS stands at the intersection of language and politics, monitoring over 1,000 media outlets in 30+ languages across Canada. Our multilingual insights reveal what polls miss and focus groups can’t reach—the authentic voices shaping the nation’s political future. As Canada’s federal election campaign reaches its midpoint, much of the mainstream political discourse remains focused on U.S. tariffs, economic sovereignty, and leadership styles. However, multilingual and ethnic media across the country are drawing attention to a broader range of issues that reflect the concerns of Canada’s diverse communities.
Recent monitoring by MIREMS (Multilingual International Research and Ethnic Media Services) reveals that while some themes overlap with national coverage, others highlight different priorities rooted in local and cultural contexts. U.S. Trade Tensions: A Shared Concern Framed Differently Coverage of Canada-U.S. trade relations appears prominently in many ethnic outlets, though each frames the issue through the lens of its community. Toronto’s Spanish-language Correo Canadiense supported Canada’s response to U.S. tariffs, describing countermeasures as necessary and encouraging readers to support Hispanic-owned businesses as both an economic and cultural contribution. In Malaysia, The Edge published an opinion piece praising Canada’s measured approach to the trade dispute, presenting it as an example for smaller countries navigating global trade challenges. Closer to home, OMNI News Italian Edition reported from York South–Weston–Etobicoke, where Liberal candidate Ahmed Hussen named economic pressure from the U.S. as a top issue. A local business owner described the current economic uncertainty as one of the most difficult periods he has experienced in Canada. Local Issues Remain Central: Housing, Safety, and Economic Stability Beyond foreign policy, ethnic media reports show strong attention to local concerns—particularly housing affordability, community safety, and cost of living. In Calgary Centre, OMNI News Filipino Edition covered housing as a key issue. Green Party candidate Jayden Baldonado noted the financial challenges many are facing, while NDP candidate Beau Shaw proposed converting vacant downtown buildings into affordable housing. Punjabi-language outlet PTC North America focused on community safety following Prime Minister Mark Carney’s campaign stop in Brampton. His announcement of plans to expand RCMP staffing and increase border enforcement was linked to concerns about crime and illicit drug flow—issues raised frequently by residents, according to local Liberal candidate Sonia Sidhu. Energy Transition: A Broader View of Calgary’s Economy Energy policy, especially in Calgary, is also receiving attention. In the Filipino-language broadcast, Liberal candidate Lindsay Luhnau emphasized Calgary’s broader capabilities in energy innovation, suggesting the city’s future includes not only oil and gas but also clean energy technologies. This reflects an evolving conversation in some communities about balancing traditional industries with environmental and economic sustainability. The Role of Representation Ethnic media also focused on the importance of candidate representation. In Filipino media, Jayden Baldonado’s candidacy for the Green Party received attention despite his lesser-known profile. His participation in the race was seen as meaningful for representation, particularly among younger Filipino-Canadians. These stories suggest that for many communities, the presence of candidates with shared cultural backgrounds plays an important role in fostering engagement with the political process. Summary of Key Themes from Ethnic Media MIREMS’ multilingual media review identifies several recurring themes:
MIREMS monitors and analyzes over 1,000 media sources in more than 30 languages across Canada, offering insight into the perspectives of culturally and linguistically diverse communities. As Canada approaches the April 28 federal election amidst ongoing U.S. trade tensions, MIREMS multilingual media monitoring reveals how diverse cultural communities are discussing the campaign through their native-language media. The emerging narratives provide valuable insights into how key election issues resonate differently across Canada's multicultural landscape.
Leadership Perspectives Across Cultural Media Chinese, Punjabi, and Spanish-language media present various perspectives on the Carney-Poilievre leadership dynamic. A Cantonese-language report from CHMB in Vancouver discussed security officials' concerns about "China-linked cyber operations targeting Carney" through WeChat. Similarly, Conservative-leaning Chinese media outlet Sing Tao reported on cybersecurity challenges facing both major parties during the campaign. Punjabi-language programs reflect divided community opinions. While CJMR noted, "Currently, Liberal Party leader Carney has significant support among some voters," Red FM countered with commentary that "Poilievre's economic message is resonating with small business owners in the community who are concerned about inflation." Spanish-language commentator Jorge Garcia on CHHA Voces Latinas offered analysis of both leaders: "Carney brings financial expertise but faces questions about his connection to everyday Canadians," while "Poilievre has developed a strong political brand focused on affordability, though his adjustment to Trump's economic policies presents new campaign challenges." Ukrainian media covered Stephen Harper's endorsement of Poilievre at an Edmonton rally, with Nash Edmonton highlighting "strong Conservative support within the Ukrainian-Canadian community." South Asian English reporting noted Carney's ceremonial visit to the BAPS Swaminarayan temple in Toronto, while also mentioning Poilievre's outreach to Hindu community leaders in British Columbia last month. Nomination Processes Scrutinized Across Parties Nomination controversies have emerged in multiple parties. Punjabi-language media reported that in Brampton, "approximately 500 members of the Conservative Party joined the Liberal Party" after candidate selection disagreements. OMNI News quoted political analyst Balraj Singh: "Candidate selection processes have created tensions in several communities, affecting local campaign dynamics." Similar issues appeared elsewhere. Calgary's Diversity Magazine reported that "both Liberal and Conservative riding associations have experienced internal disagreements over candidate selection," while OMNI News quoted Mount Royal University Political Science Professor Lori Williams on potential electoral impacts: "In close races, community connections matter significantly, and disruptions to those relationships can affect any party's chances." Immigration Discussions Reflect Multiple Viewpoints Media across languages highlight diverse community perspectives on immigration policy. Hindi-language ABP News quoted Liberal candidate Sunjiv Raval: "The country needs immigrants, but there should be a balance." Mandarin-language Fairchild Television featured Conservative candidate Alice Wong emphasizing "the importance of sustainable immigration levels that align with infrastructure development and housing availability." The South Asian Link published perspectives from both major parties, noting that "Liberals advocate for targeted immigration adjustments while maintaining family reunification programs" while "Conservatives propose more significant policy revisions focused on economic integration and credential recognition." Economic Policies and U.S. Relations Coverage of economic issues, particularly regarding U.S. tariffs, varies across language media. Hindi-language Dainik Jagran characterized the tariffs as "primarily political rather than economic," while Korean-language media emphasized potential industry-specific impacts on Canadian-Korean businesses. The Print (Hindi) discussed manufacturing sector implications: "Indian automotive component manufacturers with facilities in Canada and Mexico may see limited impact due to USMCA provisions." Meanwhile, Italian-language Corriere Canadese highlighted concerns from Canadian-Italian business owners about "supply chain disruptions affecting small enterprises regardless of which party forms government." Election Integrity Discussions Multiple language media outlets have reported on election integrity concerns. Nash Vancouver (Russian) covered "efforts to spread misinformation about Canada's economy and leadership," while Chinese-language Sing Tao reported on Elections Canada's enhanced monitoring systems. On CHLO 530 AM, Punjabi-language host Amandeep Singh discussed foreign interference broadly, urging listeners "to evaluate information critically." Polish-language media similarly emphasized the importance of media literacy during campaigns, with Gazeta informing readers about official election information resources. Polling and Predictions Ethnic media reflects the diversity of polling interpretations. While former Conservative MP Gurmant Singh Grewal told Punjabi audiences on Sher-e-Punjab radio that "the Liberals have potential to form a minority government," Chinese-language Fairchild Television cited different polling data suggesting "Conservatives maintaining strength in several key battlegrounds." Portuguese-language publication Wave provided an overview of Canada's political system for Brazilian-Canadian voters, emphasizing that "polling remains fluid with significant regional variations." Arabic-language Al Sharq newspaper noted that "both major parties see paths to forming government, with outcomes likely determined by regional battlegrounds." Looking Ahead As election day approaches, ethnic media perspectives reflect Canada's multicultural diversity. These varied viewpoints underscore the importance of monitoring multilingual media to understand how Canada's cultural communities are engaging with this election occurring against the backdrop of economic challenges and international pressures. MIREMS will continue to provide comprehensive multilingual media intelligence throughout the campaign period, offering insights into how Canada's diverse communities are evaluating party platforms, leadership qualities, and policy priorities across the political spectrum. As Canada navigates both a federal election and an escalating trade dispute with the United States, ethnic media outlets are providing crucial perspectives often overlooked in mainstream coverage. MIREMS's monitoring reveals how these publications frame economic tensions and political campaigns through distinct cultural lenses, offering valuable insights into the concerns of diverse communities.
US-Canada Trade Conflict Dominates Headlines The trade war has become a central focus across multiple language publications. Hindi-language outlet Satya Hindianalyzed Trump's 25% automotive tariff in depth, noting its ambitious $100 billion revenue target while highlighting potential global supply chain disruptions. South Asian English-language publication The Indian Express adopted a more global economic perspective, connecting the tariffs to market instability and citing Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell's inflation warnings. Their reporting noted investment banks now forecast a 60% probability of global recession by year-end. In a distinctive angle, Hindi-language Dainik Hindustan examined India's diplomatic response to the tensions, contrasting its approach with Canada's more confrontational stance. Their analysis suggested India might leverage the situation by proposing tariff reductions to strengthen US relations. Campaign Coverage Reflects Community Priorities Polish-language media Goniec devoted significant coverage to Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre's visit to a Polish delicatessen in Mississauga, including a 20-minute video segment. Their reporting captured Poilievre learning to cut ham while delivering his tax-cutting message, emphasizing the enthusiastic community reception and his promise of a 15% income tax reduction. By contrast, Punjabi-language PTC North America highlighted Liberal candidate Kamal Khera's Brampton campaign launch, focusing on community support despite inclement weather. Their coverage explicitly connected Carney's leadership credentials to the trade crisis, portraying him as uniquely qualified to address the tariff situation. Gender Politics and Housing Skepticism Punjabi-language Radio Humsafar aired an illuminating discussion on gender divisions in political preferences, with callers suggesting women express concerns about Conservative crime policies while men question Liberal economic management. This analysis offers nuanced insight into potential voting patterns within specific cultural communities. Russian-language Toronto Express published a critical examination of Liberal housing promises, describing election season as a "season of promises" where commitments often exceed delivery. The article referenced unfulfilled 2019 housing pledges under Trudeau and questioned the feasibility of Carney's plan to double housing construction, illustrating how past government performance shapes current campaign reception. Key Trends in Ethnic Media Coverage Our monitoring identifies several significant patterns:
As the election approaches amid growing economic uncertainty, these diverse media perspectives provide essential intelligence on how Canada's multilingual communities are engaging with the high-stakes campaign. Their coverage reveals community-specific concerns that often remain invisible in mainstream reporting but will likely influence voting decisions across the country. Analysis of recent ethnic media coverage reveals how global tensions, particularly U.S. trade threats, are dominating election discourse across Canada's diverse communities.
Trump's Shadow "We can no longer depend on our neighbour to the south," warns Jorge Correia in Montreal's A Voz de Portugal, calling for leadership capable of navigating a world where "us first means the strongest first." Former Alberta MLA Thomas Lukaszuk, speaking on CJSR 88.5 FM's Nasze Radio Canada, observes that traditional campaign issues have been overshadowed by one question: which leader can best handle Trump's America? Carney vs. Poilievre Nash Montreal provides detailed analysis of both leaders' tax proposals, questioning how either can fund promised cuts while facing NATO pressure to increase defense spending. On Radio Humsafar, callers discuss Poilievre's challenges in the GTA, particularly his strained relationship with regional Conservative leaders. Meanwhile, Guntas Radio reports growing Liberal support, crediting Carney's firm stance on Canadian sovereignty. Diaspora Perspectives A news anchor on Sanjha Virsa reveals that Punjabis, who felt close to Trudeau, are cautiously warming to Carney despite his stricter immigration policies. The Alberta Jewish News reports on CIJA's "More Than Just a Vote" campaign, highlighting security concerns and hate accountability as key election issues. Foreign Interference Security concerns feature prominently, with Radio Humsafar callers debating foreign interference allegations and security clearance requirements for leadership candidates. This intersection of international relations and domestic politics particularly resonates with immigrant communities." |
|